Father James A. Healey, 1922-25
Father Edward H. Kelly, 1925-27
Father James H. McGinness, 1927-30
Father Michael J. Hegerich, 1929-30
Father Leo Gattes, 1930
Father Francis R. Mullen, 1930-41
Father Thomas C. Brown, 1931-35
Father Joseph E. Janok, 1936-38
Father Joseph F. McCarthy, 1937-44
Father Francis A. Glenn, 1938-47
Father Ferris J. Guay, 1941-46
Father Thomas M. Nee, 1944-45
Father Joseph A. Kopecky, 1945-48
Father Elroy I. Grundler, 1946-48
Father Vincent Hallstein, 1947-49
Father James A. O'Rourke, 1948-49
Father John L. Phillips, 1948-53
Father Henry J. Donabedian, 1949-52
Father Charles Roach, 1952-57
Father Francis A. Nazimek, 1953-58
Father George Stuparitz, 1957-60
Father Joseph R. Bryan, 1958-62
Father Zygmunt V. Szarnicki, 1960-65
Father Robert G. Turner, 1962-63
Father Thomas J. Hanlon, 1963-65

Father Harry E. Parsons, 1965-70
Father William McDonough, 1965-67
Father Francis Jurewicz, 1967-71
Father Bernard Rabik, 1970
Father Paul Brandimarti, 1970-74
Father Asterio T. Duque, 1971-72
Father Robert A. Norton, 1972-77
Father John W. Rebel, 1974-76
Father William R. Bovard, 1976
Father William B. Yockey, 1978
Father Richard Tusky, 1978-82
Father John P. Gallaher, 1980-96
Father Kenneth R. White, 1982-87
Father William Blewitt, 1984-89
Father Thomas Wagner, 1988-92
Father James R. Torquato, 1990-92
Father Joseph Reschick, 1992-93
Father John P. Hickey, 1992-2001
Father Joseph Knorr, 1993-94
Father Paul Merkovsky, 1994-2000
Father Michael Yaksick, 2000-02
Father Michael J. Stumpf, 2001-04
Father John Gizler, 2004-08
Father Richard Tusky, 2008-Present